While many discussions around users’ privacy when using digital technologies say that publicity comes at the expense of privacy, Jurgenson and Rey (2012) debate that privacy and publicity are intertwined and mutually reinforcing. There is not a trade-off for one or the other.
Jurgenson and Rey’s idea that digital technologies are associated with an increase of privacy and publicity is also touched on by danah boyd and Sonia Livingstone.
boyd (2010) highlights a negative of the relationship between publicity and privacy being so closely related. The negative that boyd discusses is that people do not alter their social behaviour to suit the digital technology that they are engaging with, that people regularly calculate that there is not much to lose in making their information public online. boyd talks about how people experience public and private in unmediated situations, that is in real conversations face to face (as public and private is not binary in these situations either) to demonstrate how people behave online using the same decision making process they do offline. This behaviour becomes a problem as people regularly calculate that there is not much to lose in making their information public online where environments are “not nearly as stabilized as offline ones” (boyd 2010).
This is the trailer of a documentary directed by Cullen Hoback called Terms & Conditions May Apply. Holback is aiming to raise awareness through the documentary and help people understand how companies use consumer’s information. An article by Hoback was also published on theguardian.com
People are unaware of the instability of the online environment and how it may change outside of their control (boyd, 2010). For many users of social media, the rules around privacy can change without their consultation, for example when Facebook changed the default privacy setting so that users’ information was shared with “Everyone” automatically unless a user manually changed their settings. Many people ignored a message that alerted them to the change and their pages were now public.
boyd (2010) states that privacy is about having control of how information flows. Helen Nissenbaum from the New York University also discusses the idea that privacy becomes a concern when the information flow in digital technologies is disrupted.
While people’s behaviour is still adapting to digital technologies, it is a positive that people are concerned about their privacy when using digital platforms. A recent survey by the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (2013) showed that only nine per cent of Australians (surveyed) trust social media websites to protect their information.
The OAIC produced a short video about their findings of the “Community Attitudes to Privacy” survey.
Livingstone (2008) studied the way that youth create their online identity and the content they produce to post on social media platforms. A positive result from this study showed that youth do have concerns about the privacy of the information they post online. Livingstone found that youth think carefully about what, how and to whom they are revealing their information, further they pointed out how affordances of social media such as the privacy settings can “limit their self-expression”. The concept reveal and conceal is also discussed by Jurgenson and Rey when they cite Jeff Jarvis. The idea discussed is that users want more privacy so that they can share more, “Users’ are also seeking greater privacy so that they feel comfortable sharing more” (Jarvis as cited in Jurgenson and Rey 2012).
References:
boyd, d 2010, Making sense of Privacy and Publicity, viewed 12 November 2013, http://www.danah.org/papers/talks/2010/SXSW2010.html
Jurgenson, N & Rey, PJ 2012, Unlike us Reader Social Media Monopolies and Their Alternatives, viewed 8 October 2013, http://issuu.com/instituteofnetworkcultures/docs/unlikeus
Livingstone, S 2008 ‘Taking risky opportunities in youthful content creation: teenagers’ use of social networking sites for intimacy, privacy and self-expression’, New Media & Society, vol. 10. pp. 393-411
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner 2013, OAIC Community Attitudes to Privacy survey Research Report 2013, viewed 9 November 2013, http://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy/privacy-resources/privacy-reports/oaic-community-attitudes-to-privacy-survey-research-report-2013





